Contact Form

Papa's Pizza and Pasta
Pizza Pasta Italian Chicken Dessert Noodles Salads Sandwiches Seafood Soup Subs Wraps
Food Types
Healthy Options Kids Menu Vegetarian Options Quick Bite Gluten Free Options Vegan Options
Business Hours
Mon - Sun: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Carryout Hours
Mon - Sat: 11:00 AM - 9:45 PM
Sun: Noon - 9:45 PM
Delivery Hours
Mon - Sun: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
See what our customers are saying!

Great tasting pizza! You ask for pepperoni and you get plenty. This is now my favorite local spot.

-A. Tovar


The best pizzeria in Farmingdale by far. Their pies and slices are massive. The toppings are plentiful. Ask for extra cheese & you get EXTRA CHEESE!

-Carlton B.


My husband & I are a bit picky when it comes to our pizza. We were having a hard time finding good pizza in our area, until we tried Lennys. We always order our pies well done. Lenny's cooked it perfectly. We've been getting pies about 1x a week and it has been consistently cooked exactly as we order it. When we get toppings they are fresh and the amounts are generous. Staff is very friendly and the place is clean. I've also tried their calzone, it too was delicious, perfectly cooked and a generous portion.

-Jennifer C.


One of the best pizza spots in New York. The pizza is so delicious. Next time I'm in the area I will definitely come back!!!

-Joshua Z.